Rented a 2011 Nissan Versa and put 800 miles on it in a day

Would rent again.  Averaged around 35mpg for the entire trip and that was using the a/c and traveling a guesstimated 75mph on average, 90% on the interstate.  It had most of the perks including cruise control, thank goodness.  It handled fairly well although it seemed to jerk around a bit with the slightest breeze.  The rain didn't stop for the majority of the first leg (400 miles) but if I hydroplaned at all I did not notice and I didn't bother to slow down too much...  :)

Overall a good experience and it only cost $60 which included the full coverage insurance.